Managing at scale: Critical account health metrics for Amazon agencies

Why Account Health Becomes Harder at Agency Scale

As Amazon agencies grow, visibility becomes the biggest challenge. Whether an agency manages 10 accounts or 100+, the complexity increases exponentially. Each account has dozens or hundreds of ASINs, multiple advertising programs, inventory dependencies, and retail health signals that can impact performance overnight.

In this session, Kenton Snyder and Sreenath Reddy break down how agencies can systematically monitor account health at scale—without spending hours logging into individual accounts or reacting too late to critical issues.

The focus is simple: how to surface the right signals early, respond quickly, and stay proactive instead of reactive.

The Core Problem Agencies Face on Amazon

Most agencies deal with three compounding challenges:

1. Too many accounts and ASINs to monitor manually
2. Too many signals that impact performance (buy box, suppressions, inventory, ads)
3. Too little time to act once something breaks

By the time many agencies notice a problem—like a suppressed ASIN, lost buy box, or stockout—sales have already been impacted. Clients then come asking questions, forcing agencies into a reactive posture.

The goal is not to prevent issues entirely. The goal is to catch critical issues early enough to limit revenue loss and maintain trust with clients.

Proactive vs Reactive Amazon Account Management

A reactive agency:

• Learns about issues after sales drop
• Responds when clients raise concerns
• Spends time explaining problems instead of solving them

A proactive agency:

• Identifies problems before clients notice
• Communicates issues with clear next steps
• Adjusts ads, inventory planning, or strategy in advance

As brands mature, expectations shift. Clients increasingly expect agencies to surface problems proactively, even if those issues fall slightly outside traditional ad management.

The Critical Amazon Account Health Signals Agencies Must Track

1. Buy Box & ASIN Suppressions

Buy box loss and ASIN suppressions are among the fastest ways to lose revenue on Amazon.

Agencies must monitor:

• Drops in buy box percentage over time
• Complete buy box loss on priority ASINs
• ASIN suppressions due to pricing, content, or compliance changes

Even for ad-only agencies, buy box issues directly impact advertising delivery and performance. Knowing about these changes early allows agencies to:

• Alert brands immediately
• Adjust ad spend to avoid wasted budget
• Escalate issues before rankings and sales decline further

2. Inventory Health & Weeks of Cover

Inventory is one of the most underestimated drivers of Amazon performance.

Key metrics to monitor include:

• Weeks of Cover (WOC) — how long inventory will last based on sales velocity
• ASINs approaching low inventory thresholds
• Actual stockouts

Running out of stock can erase months of ranking gains in days. Agencies should:

• Monitor inventory proactively on key ASINs
• Flag products falling below defined WOC thresholds
• Adjust advertising immediately when stock becomes constrained

Even if an agency does not manage inventory directly, early alerts enable better ad decisions and stronger client communication.

3. Advertising Performance Anomalies

Beyond daily optimization, agencies must watch for large performance shifts that compound over time.

Important signals include:

• Sudden ACoS spikes
• Significant spend increases or decreases
• Flat sales despite rising spend
• Conversion rate drops

Catching these anomalies early—within days instead of weeks—prevents small issues from turning into month-long performance problems.

4. Budget Pacing & Spend Control

Pacing errors quietly destroy performance.

Examples include:

• Spending 75% of monthly budget halfway through the month
• Under-spending early and rushing spend later

Agencies need daily visibility into:

• Budget vs spend
• Over-pacing and under-pacing
• Account-level and portfolio-level trends

Correcting pacing within a day or two protects month-end performance and client confidence.

How Quickly Agencies Need to Respond

Different signals require different response timelines:

• Buy box loss or ASIN suppression → same day
• Sharp revenue decline → within 1–2 days
• Ad performance anomalies → within days
• Low inventory warnings → within the week
• Budget pacing issues → within 1–2 days

Without a centralized system, hitting these response windows consistently becomes impossible at scale.

Building an Amazon Agency Health Framework

Agencies cannot log into every account daily and manually inspect every signal. Instead, Kenton outlines a scalable framework:

Daily Portfolio-Level Monitoring

• Overall revenue trends
• Budget pacing
• Critical alerts (stockouts, suppressions, buy box loss)

Weekly Account-Level Reviews

• Inventory trends
• Buy box percentage changes
• Advertising anomalies
• Performance by ad type (Sponsored Ads, DSP)

As-Needed SKU-Level Deep Dives

• Diagnosing root causes
• Adjusting ads or strategy
• Coordinating with clients on fixes

This layered approach keeps daily work efficient while preserving depth when it matters.

What an Amazon Agency Health Dashboard Looks Like

Kenton walks through an example of a centralized agency health dashboard that allows teams to:

• See top-line performance across all clients
• Track budget pacing across accounts
• Identify critical ASIN-level issues instantly
• Estimate revenue impact of unresolved problems
• Prioritize actions by severity and urgency

Instead of spending hours clicking through Seller Central and Ads Console, agencies can identify what needs attention in minutes.

Why This Matters for Client Trust & Retention

Proactive account health management directly impacts:

• Client satisfaction
• Strategic credibility
• Agency margins
• Long-term retention

Clients trust agencies that:

• Flag problems early
• Explain causes clearly
• Take action before performance collapses

This shift—from reactive reporting to proactive system-driven monitoring—is what separates scalable agencies from those that struggle as they grow.

Why Ads-Only Agencies Still Need Full Visibility

Even agencies focused solely on advertising cannot ignore retail signals.

Inventory, buy box, pricing, and content changes all influence:

• Ad delivery
• Conversion rates
• Ranking
• ROAS

Understanding these signals allows agencies to:

• Make smarter ad decisions
• Avoid wasted spend
• Participate in higher-level strategic conversations

Automating Account Health at Scale

Sreenath Reddy reinforces that modern Amazon agencies face signal overload.

With Amazon expanding data availability and brands operating across multiple channels (Amazon, TikTok Shop, DTC), agencies must invest in systems that:

• Process signals automatically
• Surface insights quickly
• Reduce manual analysis time
• Improve operational margins

Automation is no longer optional—it is essential for scale.

Key Takeaways for Amazon Agencies

• Account health issues compound quickly at scale
• Buy box, suppressions, inventory, and ads are deeply interconnected
• Proactive monitoring builds trust and reduces churn
• Centralized dashboards save time and protect margins
• Agencies that master signal processing gain a competitive edge

‍